Macdonald Forest Hills Hotel & Spa Aberfoyle , Aberfoyle (Stirling)

The hotel has a beautiful setting with stunning views of the loch and mountains, making it a great spot for relaxation. The rooms are spacious and comfortable, though there are some minor cosmetic issues that could be improved. While the service is generally friendly, I found the staff sometimes struggled to follow through on requests, which felt a bit frustrating. Dining could definitely be better value for the money, as I found it on the expensive side for what was offered.

Overall, my stay was pleasant with a beautiful location that offered great views and plenty of leisure activities. The rooms were lovely, but it was a letdown that I didn’t get the promised mountain view and the dining experience was not what I expected. While the staff was attentive, service could have felt more welcoming. Still, it felt like a good value for a relaxing getaway.

I had a wonderful stay at this hotel, with clean and spacious rooms boasting stunning views. The staff was exceptionally friendly and welcoming, which made my visit even more enjoyable. However, the dining experience left something to be desired, as breakfast options were a bit lacking. Still, the large pool area was a great bonus and provided a lovely place to relax. Overall, the hotel is a great value for money, despite a few minor drawbacks.

I recently stayed at this hotel and found it to have a lovely location, especially with the autumn colors all around. However, the room I got was somewhat scruffy and felt tired, and the breakfast situation was pretty understaffed. Overall, it had great potential but there were definitely some downsides during my stay.

I recently stayed at this hotel and overall, it had some real highlights, particularly with its stunning location and friendly staff. However, the rooms felt a bit outdated and lacked modern amenities like air conditioning. The dining experience was also disappointing with limited breakfast options. While it's in a beautiful area, the value for money could be better, especially regarding dining.

My stay at the hotel had its ups and downs. The location was absolutely stunning, surrounded by picturesque views and plenty of activities. The staff were incredibly friendly and helpful, especially Kirsty from housekeeping. However, the rooms could have been better in terms of ventilation and accessibility. Overall, it's a nice spot, but be aware of the room issues if you need better air flow or wheelchair access.

I had a lovely time at the hotel, with spacious, clean rooms that offered a great view of the loch. The service was generally good, especially from one of the waiters, but it felt like the staff could have been more welcoming. The location was breathtaking, ideal for quiet walks and family gatherings. Dining was a mixed bag; while some dishes were delicious, others were just okay, with small portions. Overall, it had a good vibe but could improve on service and dining consistency.

I recently stayed at this hotel and found the location to be stunning with beautiful views, perfect for walks around Loch Ard. However, the room cleanliness could use some improvement as I found remnants from previous guests. The service was quite good, but there were some hiccups during check-in that left me waiting for over an hour. Dining was a mixed experience, with some tasty options but also overpriced items that didn't meet expectations.

I had a pretty good stay overall at this hotel. It was a beautiful location, perfect for a relaxing getaway, especially if you're a dog owner, since they had great pet amenities. The facilities like the spa and pool were enjoyable, but I feel the price was on the higher side considering breakfast and dinner weren't included. Also, some service aspects could be improved.

I stayed at this hotel recently, and while the rooms were clean and comfortable with fantastic views over the loch, I was disappointed that they didn’t quite match the photos I saw online. The staff was friendly and went out of their way to help, but the dining experience left a lot to be desired. Overall, it's a decent place, but there are definitely areas that need improvement.